All products are currently 15% off through October 31.
Benton & Bean
Shop
About
Cart (
0
)
0
Benton & Bean
Shop
About
Contact us
Halloween Plush
Haunt the Bear | Pumpkin Charm | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
7.65
$9.00
Spinner the Spider | Creepy Crawler | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Buddy
$
11.90
$14.00
Oktoberfest Winnie the Pooh | Bavarian Bear | Vintage Disney Store Bean Bag
$
10.20
$12.00
Slither the Snake | Camo Jungle Crawler | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Buddy
$
11.05
$13.00
Haunt the Bear | Pumpkin Patch Bear | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Buddy
$
15.30
$18.00
Merlin the Dragon | Medium Midnight Fire Dragon | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Boo
$
29.75
$35.00
all Halloween Plush
Thanksgiving Plush
Gobbles the Turkey | Festive Feathered Friend | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
5.95
$7.00
Sly the Fox | Woodland Wanderer | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
5.95
$7.00
Roam the Buffalo | Prairie Wanderer | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
5.95
$7.00
Fredrick the Fox | Woodland Golden-Eyed Friend | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
9.35
$11.00
Chipper the Chipmunk | Woodland Trail Scout | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
6.80
$8.00
Percy the Owl | Wide-Eyed Woodland Pal | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Boo
$
8.50
$10.00
all Thanksgiving Plush
Christmas Plush
TY Christmas Jingle Beans Collection | Festive Holiday Favorites | Mint Heart Tags TY Beanie
$
5.10
$6.00
CAND-e the Bear | Candy Cane Christmas | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
10.20
$12.00
Kringle the Santa Bear | Santa Claus Cutie | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
10.20
$12.00
2002 Holiday Bear | Reindeer Christmas | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
7.65
$9.00
2001 Holiday Bear | Evergreen Christmas | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
7.65
$9.00
Season's Greetings the Bear | Christmas Scarf | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
11.90
$14.00
all Christmas Plush
TY Bean Babies
Lullaby the Lamb | Gentle Little Dreamer | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
11.05
$13.00
Dizzy the Dog | Spotted Sidekick | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
6.80
$8.00
Pouch the Kangaroo | Down Under Dreamer | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
6.80
$8.00
Stinky the Skunk | Woodland Stinker | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
5.95
$7.00
Rowdy the Dog | Countryside Puppy Pal | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
8.50
$10.00
Crunch the Shark | Friendly Ocean Chomper | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
6.80
$8.00
all TY Bean Babies
TY Bean Baby Bears
Decade the Bear | Pink Anniversary Celebration | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
7.65
$9.00
Baby Girl the Bear | Little Bundle of Joy | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
5.95
$7.00
Popcorn the Bear | Bear of the Month | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
6.80
$8.00
Blue the Patriotic Bear | Star-Spangled Sweetie | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
5.95
$7.00
The End the Bear | Millennium Farewell Bear | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
7.65
$9.00
Millennium the Bear | Turn of the Century | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Baby
$
4.67
$5.50
all TY Bean Baby Bears
TY Bean Buddies
America the Bear TY Buddy & Baby | Patriotic Pride Duo | Mint Heart Tags TY Set
$
11.90
$14.00
Libearty the Bear | Stars & Stripes Classic | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Buddy
$
10.20
$12.00
Patti the Platypus | Purple River Friend | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Buddy
$
11.90
$14.00
Floppity the Bunny | Lavender Bunny Love | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Buddy
$
13.60
$16.00
Hippity the Bunny | Springtime Sweetheart | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Buddy
$
12.75
$15.00
Seal the Seal | Snowy Sea Sweetheart | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Buddy
$
13.60
$16.00
all TY Bean Buddies
TY Bean Boos
Nightcap the Ghost | Spooky Spirit | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Boo
$
5.95
$7.00
Owlette the Owl | Pink Feathered Sweetie | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie Boo
$
8.50
$10.00
Slush the Dog | Icy Blue Husky | Mint Heart Tag Retired TY Beanie Boo
$
17.00
$20.00
all TY Bean Boos
TY Attic Treasures
Debbie the Duck Ty Attic Treasures | Sunny Puddle Pal | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie
$
20.40
$24.00
Kit the Kitty | Cozy Windowsill Cat | Mint Heart Tag TY Attic Treasures
$
17.00
$20.00
all TY Attic Treasures
TY Pillow Pals
Baba the Lamb | Purple Lullaby | Mint Heart Tag TY Pillow Pal
$
8.92
$10.50
Baba the Lamb | Sweet Little Lamb | NEAR Mint Heart Tag TY Pillow Pal
$
8.92
$10.50
Clover the Rabbit | Lucky Little Bunny | Mint Heart Tag TY Pillow Pal
$
8.92
$10.50
Bruiser the Dog | Sleepy Puppy Pal | Mint Heart Tag TY Pillow Pal
$
8.92
$10.50
Red the Bull | Barnyard Buddy | Mint Heart Tag TY Pillow Pal
$
8.92
$10.50
Sherbet the Bear Ty Pillow Pal | Pastel Cuddle Buddy | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie
$
8.92
$10.50
all TY Pillow Pals
TY Classics
Misty the Seal | Ivory Arctic Sweetheart | TY Classic Plush Mint Buddy Size
$
15.30
$18.00
Teddybearsary the Bear | Centennial Teddy | TY Classic Plush Mint Tags
$
8.50
$10.00
Charlie the Dog Ty Classic | Golden Spaniel Pup | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie
$
11.90
$14.00
Cha Cha the Monkey Ty Classic | Curious Monkey Companion | Mint Heart Tag
$
11.90
$14.00
Bows the Bunny TY Classic | Spring Sweetheart | Mint Heart Tag TY Classic
$
11.90
$14.00
Coop the Chick TY Classic | Sunshine Hatchling | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie
$
11.90
$14.00
all TY Classics
TY Punkies
T-Bone the Cow Ty Punkies | Fuzzy Farm Friend | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie
$
8.50
$10.00
Marbles the Moose Ty Punkies | Bright Colorful Moose | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie
$
10.20
$12.00
all TY Punkies
TY Bean Boppers
Festive Franny Ty Bean Boppers | Christmas Cheer | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie
$
12.75
$15.00
Cuddly Crystal Ty Bean Boppers | Fanclub Favorite | Mint Heart Tag TY Beanie
$
11.05
$13.00
all TY Bean Boppers
TY McDonalds Teenies
1998 McDonald's Teenie Bean Babies | Sealed & New Condition | Sold Individually TY Beanie
$
2.97
$3.50
1996 McDonald's Teenie Bean Babies | Sealed & New Condition | Sold Individually TY Beanie
$
2.97
$3.50
2000 McDonald's Teenie Bean Babies | Sealed & New Condition | Sold Individually TY Beanie
$
2.97
$3.50
1999 McDonald's Teenie Bean Babies | Sealed & New Condition | Sold Individually TY Beanie
$
2.97
$3.50
all TY McDonalds Teenies
All Other TY Products
Lola the Llama | Rainbow Sequin Sparkle | Mint Heart Tag TY Flippables
$
15.30
$18.00
Confetti the Cat | Colorful Sparkle | Mint Heart Tag TY Flippables
$
8.50
$10.00
all All Other TY Products
Puffkins
Gertie the Gerbil | Cuddly Little Critter | Puffkins Collectible Plush
$
5.95
$7.00
Honey the Bear | Honey Golden Cuddle Bear | Puffkins Collectible Plush
$
5.95
$7.00
Cinnamon the Cat | Cozy Golden Kitty | Puffkins Collectible Plush
$
6.80
$8.00
Scooter the Chipmunk | Woodland Cheeky Charmer | Puffkins Collectible Plush
$
5.95
$7.00
Matilda the Kangaroo | Outback Cuddle Hopper | Puffkins Collectible Plush
$
5.95
$7.00
Zack the Zebra | Wild Striped Cutie | Puffkins Collectible Plush
$
5.95
$7.00
all Puffkins
Disney
Winnie the Pooh | Classic Storybook Sweetie | Vintage Disney Store Plush
$
6.80
$8.00
all Disney
All Other Plushies/Toys
Peach Barn Bull Plush | Roadside Country Charm | Souvenir Collectible
$
5.10
$6.00
YooHoo the Bush Baby | Scottish Sweetheart | Aurora YooHoo & Friends Plush
$
11.90
$14.00
Nibbles the Koala | Big-Eyed Buddy | Keel Toys Animotsu Plush
$
11.90
$14.00
all All Other Plushies/Toys
0 items in your cart
Close
Keep shopping! :)
Legal imprint
Close
